Unfair labour practices (ULPs) undermine the rights of workers and disrupt industrial harmony. In Pakistan, these practices are addressed through comprehensive legal frameworks designed to protect both employers and employees. This article delves into the nature of ULPs in Pakistan, the relevant legal provisions, and the mechanisms available for redress.
Understanding Unfair Labour Practices (ULPs)
Unfair labour practices refer to actions by employers or workers that violate labour laws, infringe upon workers' rights, or disrupt fair industrial relations. These practices can include discrimination, refusal to negotiate in good faith, intimidation, and other actions detrimental to the workforce or management.
Common Examples of ULPs:
Employer-Related ULPs:
Discrimination: Unequal treatment based on race, gender, religion, or union affiliation.
Refusal to Bargain: Avoiding negotiations with legally recognized trade unions.
Intimidation: Threatening employees to deter them from union activities.
Unlawful Deductions: Making unauthorized deductions from wages.
Worker-Related ULPs:
Coercion: Forcing other workers to join or refrain from joining a union.
Illegal Strikes: Engaging in strikes without following legal procedures.
Workplace Disruption: Intentionally slowing down work or sabotaging operations.
Legal Framework Governing ULPs in Pakistan
Pakistan's labour laws have evolved to address industrial relations and unfair labour practices. Key legislative instruments include:
Industrial Relations Ordinance, 1969: Established foundational labour laws, including provisions on ULPs.
Industrial Relations Act, 2008 (IRA 2008): Aimed to consolidate and rationalize laws related to trade unions and industrial relations.
Industrial Relations Act, 2012 (IRA 2012): Currently governs industrial relations, defining ULPs and outlining procedures for addressing them.
Key Provisions in IRA 2012:
Section 31: Defines unfair labour practices on the part of employers, including interference with the formation of trade unions and discrimination against union members.
Section 32: Outlines unfair labour practices on the part of workers and trade unions, such as coercing individuals to join unions or engaging in illegal strikes.
Role of the National Industrial Relations Commission (NIRC)
The National Industrial Relations Commission (NIRC) is pivotal in adjudicating matters related to ULPs. Established to ensure fair industrial relations, NIRC addresses:
Registration of Trade Unions: Oversees the registration process to ensure compliance with legal standards.
Adjudication of ULPs: Hears cases related to unfair labour practices and provides remedies.
Industrial Disputes Resolution: Facilitates the resolution of disputes between employers and workers to maintain industrial peace.
Addressing Complaints of Unfair Labour Practices
Workers or employers who believe they have been subjected to ULPs can seek redress through the following steps:
Filing a Complaint: Submit a formal complaint to the NIRC or the relevant Labour Court, detailing the alleged unfair practices.
Investigation: The commission or court will investigate the complaint, which may involve hearings and evidence collection.
Adjudication: Based on findings, the authority will issue a decision, which may include orders to cease the unfair practices, reinstatement of workers, or compensation.
Appeal: Parties dissatisfied with the decision can appeal to higher judicial forums within the stipulated time frame.
Case Studies Highlighting ULPs in Pakistan
Garment Industry Violations
In 2019, Human Rights Watch reported that Pakistani garment workers involved in setting up trade unions faced violence, intimidation, threats, and loss of employment. Factory owners used legal lacunas, fake unions, threats, and involuntary dismissals to prevent unions from being registered.
Pharmaceutical Sector Issues
In 2019, a group of 29 workers approached the National Industrial Relations Commission (NIRC) regarding a company's unfair labour practices. This included daily wage workers being denied benefits given to permanent workers, such as annual increments, bonuses, medical facilities, leave benefits, and group insurance.
Conclusion
Unfair labour practices pose significant challenges to industrial relations in Pakistan. The legal frameworks, particularly the Industrial Relations Act, 2012, provide mechanisms to address these issues. It is imperative for both employers and workers to be aware of their rights and obligations to foster a fair and harmonious working environment.
For detailed information on labour laws and practices, consulting legal experts or referring to official legal documents is recommended.
For More Information Visit Us : Burhan Law
